ALEXANDRIA, Alabama — A small-town pizza shop just put Northeast Alabama on the national map — and locals are not surprised one bit.
Cutter’s Pizzeria, located at 7113 U.S. Highway 431 South in Alexandria, has been named Alabama’s top pizza destination in a major nationwide ranking published by 5 Reasons to Visit.
The travel and lifestyle publication released its list, “The Top Pizza Slice in All 50 States Ranked,” selecting one standout pizzeria from each state across the country.
Cutter’s Pizzeria was Alabama’s pick.
What Made Cutter’s Stand Out Nationally
The ranking highlighted several things that set Cutter’s apart from every other pizzeria in the state.
Reviewers pointed to the restaurant’s handcrafted pizzas, generous toppings, and flavorful crust as key reasons for the selection.
The publication also noted Cutter’s commitment to fresh, quality ingredients and consistent preparation — the kind of details that keep customers coming back week after week.
A welcoming atmosphere rounded out the recognition, making it more than just a meal but an experience worth driving for.
A Local Favorite Long Before the Spotlight
For many residents in Alexandria, Oxford, and the broader Northeast Alabama region, this recognition simply confirmed what they already knew.
Cutter’s has been a go-to dining destination for pizza lovers in the area long before any national publication took notice.
With two locations — one in Alexandria and one in Oxford — the pizzeria has built a loyal customer base that spans multiple communities.
The national ranking just made it official.
What the 50-State List Represents
The guide from 5 Reasons to Visit is not a casual roundup.
It examines pizzerias across all 50 states, spotlighting restaurants that reflect the unique flavors and dining traditions of their regions.
From deep-dish spots in Illinois to classic New York-style slices on the East Coast, only one restaurant per state makes the cut.
Being selected means Cutter’s is now considered a must-visit pizza destination — not just in Alabama, but on a national level.
Northeast Alabama Is on the Pizza Map
For a community like Alexandria, this kind of recognition carries real weight.
It brings attention to a local business that has been quietly doing things the right way — fresh ingredients, consistent quality, and a dining room that feels like home.
Cutter’s Pizzeria continues to serve customers at both the Alexandria and Oxford locations, and if this national spotlight brings new visitors through the door, the community will have one more reason to be proud of what is already here.
Have you been to Cutter’s Pizzeria? Drop your favorite order in the comments — locals want to know what to try next.
